American Financial Group, Inc. Price & Performance (AFGE)

American Financial Group, Inc. announced a $2.00 per share special dividend, payable on March 28, 2025, totaling $170 million. This adds to $52 per share in special dividends declared since 2021. The company also repurchased $50 million worth of shares this year, showcasing its commitment to returning value to shareholders.12

Short interest in American Financial Group surged by 16.7% in February, reaching 1.26 million shares. This represents 1.8% of the company’s shares outstanding. The days-to-cover ratio stands at 3.0 days, reflecting increased bearish sentiment among investors despite the company's strong fundamentals.34

Investor sentiment has plummeted, with only 19% of survey respondents expecting stock gains in the next six months. Analysts suggest this fear could be a contrarian indicator, as periods of low sentiment often precede market recoveries. Factors like policy uncertainty and trade tensions are contributing to the unease.56