Home
Finance
Travel
Shopping
Academic
Library
Create a Thread
Home
Discover
Spaces
 
 
  • Court Advances Platform Liability
  • U.S. Tensions and Enforcement Context
  • Competing Perspectives on Regulation
Brazil's top court moves to hold social media liable

Brazil's Supreme Court moved closer to holding social media companies liable for illegal user content on Wednesday, with six of 11 justices voting to allow platforms like Meta, X and Microsoft to face lawsuits and fines for posts by their users. The court needs only a simple majority to pass the measure, which would mark a departure from the country's current internet regulation framework.

The ruling represents a shift in how Latin America's largest democracy approaches big tech regulation, bringing Brazil's policies closer to European Union standards while potentially escalating tensions with the United States over digital governance and free speech.

User avatar
Curated by
thgths
3 min read
Published
1,015
13
ksat.com favicon
San Antonio News, Texas News, Sports, Weather from KSAT.com, Expect More
Brazil's Supreme Court justices agree to make social media ... - KSAT
chron.com favicon
chron
Brazil's Supreme Court justices agree to make social media ... - Chron
Brazil's Supreme Court justices agree to make social media ... - Chron
ctvnews.ca favicon
ctvnews
Brazil top court agrees to make social media companies liable for ...
Brazil top court agrees to make social media companies liable for ...
yahoo.com favicon
jurist.org favicon
aldianews.com favicon
+20 sources
Brazil block on X comes into effect after judge's order
techxplore.com
Court Advances Platform Liability

Justice Gilmar Mendes cast the decisive sixth vote Wednesday, joining colleagues who have supported expanding social media companies' responsibilities beyond the current system12. Under existing law, platforms are only liable for harmful content if they refuse to comply with court orders to remove it13.

The proposed change would become law once voting concludes and results are published, though Brazil's Congress could still pass legislation to reverse the measure12. Only Justice André Mendonça has dissented, arguing that free speech on social media is essential for holding "powerful public institutions to account, including governments, political elites and digital platforms"23.

ctvnews.ca favicon
ksat.com favicon
chron.com favicon
3 sources
U.S. Tensions and Enforcement Context

The vote follows warnings from U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio about possible visa restrictions against foreign officials allegedly involved in censoring American citizens12. Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who has clashed repeatedly with X owner Elon Musk over content moderation, is reportedly among those officials23.

Brazil previously suspended X for 40 days in 2024 after the platform refused to comply with court orders to remove accounts spreading misinformation4. The company was also fined $1.4 million earlier this year for failing to provide user registration details in a disinformation case5.

ctvnews.ca favicon
ksat.com favicon
chron.com favicon
5 sources
Competing Perspectives on Regulation

Justice Flávio Dino, who voted first Wednesday, cited recent school shootings in Brazil that were "stimulated on social media," reading posts from users celebrating violence against children12. Legal experts argue platforms must be proactive rather than wait for judicial orders to remove harmful content12.

Critics warn the changes could threaten free expression as platforms might preemptively remove potentially problematic content12. The Brazilian Chamber of Digital Economy said automatic liability "favors large companies with robust legal structures, to the detriment of smaller, national players"12.

The debate intensified after supporters of former president Jair Bolsonaro used social media to spread election misinformation before ransacking government buildings in January 202312.

ksat.com favicon
chron.com favicon
2 sources
Related
How will this liability shift affect social media content moderation in Brazil
What are the potential impacts on free speech with increased platform liability
Could this move lead to more censorship or self-censorship by platforms
Discover more
Meta digs in against EU over ad model despite fine threats
Meta digs in against EU over ad model despite fine threats
Meta Platforms is digging in for a protracted regulatory battle with European Union authorities, with sources indicating the social media giant has no plans to make further changes to its controversial "pay-or-consent" advertising model despite threats of daily fines that could reach 5% of its global daily turnover. The standoff represents a high-stakes test of the EU's Digital Markets Act...
130
Uber, Instacart face skeptical judges over Seattle gig law
Uber, Instacart face skeptical judges over Seattle gig law
Uber and Instacart faced skeptical questioning from a three-judge panel at the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday as they argued that Seattle's groundbreaking gig worker protection law violates their First Amendment rights. The companies are challenging the city's App-Based Worker Deactivation Rights Ordinance, which has been in effect since January 1 and requires companies to provide...
131
Missouri AG threatens legal action over AI bias claims
Missouri AG threatens legal action over AI bias claims
Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey sent formal demand letters to Google, OpenAI, Meta and Microsoft on Tuesday, accusing their artificial intelligence chatbots of producing biased results that unfairly ranked President Donald Trump last on antisemitism among recent presidents. The Republican attorney general threatened legal action under state consumer protection laws, marking his latest...
1,496
German court orders Meta to pay €5,000 for privacy breach
German court orders Meta to pay €5,000 for privacy breach
A German court has ordered Meta to pay €5,000 to a Facebook user in a ruling that found the social media giant's tracking technology embedded across millions of websites violates European privacy laws. The Leipzig Regional Court delivered its judgment on July 4, finding that Meta's tracking pixels and software development kits collect user data without consent, breaching the General Data...
202