Based on reports from Reuters, Elon Musk has announced he will withdraw his $97.4 billion bid for OpenAI's non-profit arm if the ChatGPT maker halts plans to become a for-profit entity, escalating the ongoing dispute between Musk and the AI company he co-founded.
Elon Musk has offered to withdraw his $97.4 billion bid for OpenAI's non-profit arm under specific conditions, as revealed in a court filing on Wednesday. The filing states, "If the OpenAI board is prepared to preserve the charity's mission and stipulate to take the 'for sale' sign off its assets by halting its conversion, Musk will withdraw the bid."12
If OpenAI proceeds with its for-profit plans, Musk argues that the non-profit must be compensated "by what an arms-length buyer will pay for its assets."1
The filing describes Musk's offer as a "serious bid" aimed at furthering the charity's mission.1
U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers previously stated it was a "stretch" for Musk to claim irreparable harm if OpenAI's transition isn't blocked, but acknowledged the plausibility of Musk's claims.3
OpenAI's board lawyer, Andy Nussbaum, countered that Musk's bid "doesn't set a value for [OpenAI's] non-profit" and maintained that the non-profit is "not for sale."4
OpenAI's transition from a nonprofit to a for-profit entity reflects the challenges of balancing its ambitious mission with financial realities. Founded in 2015 with the goal of developing safe artificial general intelligence (AGI) for humanity's benefit, OpenAI initially operated on donations and open-source principles12. However, as the costs of AI research escalated, the organization realized that donations alone couldn't sustain its mission2.
In 2019, OpenAI introduced a "capped profit" subsidiary to allow external investments while maintaining its ethical commitments23.
This hybrid model attracted significant backing, including a $1 billion investment from Microsoft34.
OpenAI is now considering a full transition to a for-profit entity, potentially as a Public Benefit Corporation34.
Elon Musk, who initially contributed an estimated $44 million to OpenAI, has criticized this shift, arguing it contradicts the organization's original mission56.
The transition has sparked debates about balancing innovation with ethical oversight in AI development, highlighting the tension between OpenAI's initial goals and the financial demands of cutting-edge AI research13.
The public exchange between Elon Musk and Sam Altman over OpenAI's future has escalated into a war of words on social media. After Musk's consortium made a $97.4 billion bid for OpenAI's assets, Altman swiftly rejected the offer with a sarcastic counter-proposal on X: "No thank you but we will buy twitter for $9.74 billion if you want."12 Musk retaliated by calling Altman a "swindler" and dubbing him "Scam Altman," referencing a 2023 video where Altman claimed to have no equity in OpenAI and was working there purely out of passion.2
Altman dismissed Musk's offer, stating OpenAI is "not for sale" and suggesting it was an attempt to "slow down a competitor."3
At an AI summit in Paris, Altman further criticized Musk's bid, characterizing it as another episode in Musk's ongoing efforts to disrupt OpenAI's progress.4
The exchange highlights the deepening rift between the former collaborators and the intensifying competition in the AI industry.