NYC's Top Thrift Stores
Curated by
cdteliot
5 min read
3,685
11
New York City boasts a vibrant thrift shopping scene, offering a diverse array of vintage treasures and designer finds across its boroughs. From well-curated boutiques like Amarcord Vintage to budget-friendly chains like L Train Vintage, the city's thrift stores cater to a wide range of styles and budgets, making it a paradise for fashion enthusiasts and bargain hunters alike.
1. L Train Vintage: NYC’s Beloved Family-Owned Thrift Shopping Destination
ltrainvintagenyc.com
L Train Vintage is a family-owned business that has become a staple in New York City's thrift shopping scene, with multiple locations across Brooklyn and Manhattan
1
. Known for its extensive selection of affordable vintage and secondhand clothing, L Train Vintage offers a treasure trove of items including graphic tees, denim, outerwear, and accessories3
4
. The store's popularity stems from its budget-friendly prices, with most shirts ranging from $8 to $15 and even high-quality items like leather jackets typically priced between $40 and $504
. Shoppers can expect a diverse inventory that is constantly updated, making each visit a unique experience3
. While the stores can get crowded, especially on weekends, many customers find the hunt for unique pieces at reasonable prices well worth the effort4
5
.5 sources
2. Beacon's Closet: The Ultimate Destination for Fashion Enthusiasts in NYC
yelp.com
Beacon's Closet, a renowned thrift store chain in New York City, has established itself as a go-to destination for fashion enthusiasts seeking high-quality secondhand and vintage clothing. With multiple locations across Brooklyn and Manhattan, including Greenpoint, Park Slope, Bushwick, and the West Village, Beacon's Closet offers a meticulously curated selection of both modern and vintage pieces
1
5
. The store is known for its diverse inventory, featuring designer labels alongside unique vintage finds, making it a favorite among style-conscious New Yorkers and tourists alike3
. While prices at Beacon's Closet tend to be higher than traditional thrift stores, they remain reasonable for the quality and rarity of the items offered, with many customers praising the store's ability to democratically price their merchandise3
. The buying process at Beacon's Closet is also noteworthy, as they offer some of the highest percentages in NYC for selling or trading clothing, making it a popular choice for those looking to refresh their wardrobes1
.5 sources
3. Buffalo Exchange: NYC’s Favorite Secondhand Clothing Chain
foursquare.com
Buffalo Exchange, a popular national chain of secondhand clothing stores, has established a strong presence in New York City with multiple locations, including a notable store in Chelsea, Manhattan
3
. This thrift shop chain offers a unique blend of contemporary and vintage clothing, accessories, and shoes at mid-range prices, catering to fashion-conscious shoppers seeking both style and value. Buffalo Exchange operates on a buy-sell-trade model, allowing customers to sell their gently used clothing for cash or store credit, which contributes to a constantly rotating inventory5
. The stores are open seven days a week, with convenient hours for shoppers and sellers alike3
. Buffalo Exchange's commitment to sustainability and fashion diversity has made it a favorite among New Yorkers looking for affordable, trendy, and eco-friendly shopping options.5 sources
NYC Thrift Shop Gems (Videos)
youtube.com
Watch
youtube.com
Watch
4. Vintage Lover's Paradise: 10 ft Single by Stella Dallas in Brooklyn
trippin.world
10 ft Single by Stella Dallas, located at 285 N 6th Street in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a vintage lover's paradise known for its expertly curated selection of men's and women's clothing and accessories.
1
The store offers a vast collection of well-organized vintage and thrift items, with a particular reputation for quality vintage denim, military jackets, and cowboy boots.4
Housed in a rustic wood-and-brick interior, this thrift store provides a unique shopping experience with its large assortment of carefully categorized pieces.1
4
Shoppers can expect to find everything from leather boots and skirts to oversized sweaters and beautiful winter coats, making it a go-to destination for those seeking authentic vintage treasures in New York City.5
5 sources
5. Cure Thrift Shop: High-End Vintage Finds with a Charitable Mission in East Village
guestofaguest.com
Cure Thrift Shop, located in Manhattan's East Village, stands out as a unique non-profit thrift destination that combines high-end vintage shopping with a charitable mission. The store offers a carefully curated selection of vintage clothing, furniture, home decor, and accessories, providing thrift enthusiasts with a vibrant and eclectic shopping experience
1
2
. What sets Cure Thrift apart is its commitment to benefiting juvenile diabetes research and advocacy, with all proceeds from sales supporting this cause2
3
. The shop's well-organized, airy space features a diverse range of items, from designer resale pieces to mid-century furniture, making it a favorite among locals and tourists alike3
4
. In an exciting development, Cure Thrift is expanding its community impact with plans to open "The Market at Cure Thrift" in a neighboring storefront, which will host weekend vendor markets, specialty events, and affordable selling opportunities for second-hand sellers and artists, further emphasizing their focus on sustainability and community engagement5
.5 sources
6. Urban Jungle: East Williamsburg’s Top Spot for Affordable Vintage Finds
yelp.com
Urban Jungle, located at 118 Knickerbocker Ave in East Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a standout L Train Vintage outpost known for its massive selection and incredibly affordable prices. This thrift store is often described as the "Vintage Mecca" of New York City, offering an extensive array of vintage clothing, accessories, and more
5
. The store's vast inventory includes everything from denim and graphic tees to fur coats and vintage dresses, with prices that are notably low - many items are priced between $5 and $153
4
. Urban Jungle's popularity stems from its diverse selection and budget-friendly options, making it a favorite among thrift shoppers looking for unique finds without breaking the bank2
3
. However, due to its size and popularity, shoppers should be prepared to spend time sifting through the extensive collection to uncover hidden gems3
.5 sources
Closing Thoughts on NYC's Top Thrift Stores
New York City's thrift scene offers a diverse array of options for bargain hunters and fashion enthusiasts alike. From popular thrift chains to affordable thrift stores, the city caters to all budgets and styles. Favorite thrift stores like L Train Vintage and Beacon's Closet provide a mix of generic thrift finds and unique vintage items at a fraction of their original price. Whether you're searching for affordable clothing, secondhand clothes, or coveted vintage clothes, NYC's thrift shops deliver. Fashion-forward shoppers can score designer brands and vintage jeans without breaking the bank. The city's thrift culture not only promotes sustainable fashion but also allows New Yorkers to express their individual style through one-of-a-kind pieces
1
3
5
.5 sources
Related
Which thrift store in NYC has the best selection of vintage jeans
Are there any thrift stores in NYC known for affordable designer brands
What are the most popular thrift stores among locals in NYC
Which thrift stores in NYC offer the best deals on secondhand clothes
Where can I find the best vintage accessories in NYC
Keep Reading
San Diego's Top Thrifting Spots: A Guide for Treasure Hunters
San Diego boasts a vibrant thrifting scene, offering treasure hunters a diverse array of secondhand shops to explore. From vintage boutiques to sprawling flea markets, the city's thrift stores cater to bargain seekers and fashion enthusiasts alike, providing an eco-friendly alternative to traditional retail.
1,996
The Ultimate Guide to New York City's Best Bookstores
New York City, a literary hub teeming with independent bookstores, offers book lovers a diverse array of reading havens. From the iconic Strand Book Store with its "18 miles of books" to the charming Books Are Magic in Brooklyn, these local establishments provide unique atmospheres and carefully curated collections that cater to every bibliophile's taste.
2,729
New York's Best Farmers Markets
New York's vibrant farmers markets offer a diverse array of fresh produce, artisanal goods, and local specialties, with Union Square Greenmarket in Manhattan standing out as the crown jewel. From the bustling stalls of Rochester Public Market to the charming Saratoga Farmers' Market, these markets showcase the best of New York's agricultural bounty and culinary creativity.
1,477
Shop Till You Drop: Top Shopping Malls in Los Angeles
Los Angeles boasts an array of impressive shopping destinations, from luxury retail havens to open-air marketplaces, offering diverse experiences for shoppers of all tastes and budgets. According to various sources, standout malls like Westfield Century City, The Grove, and Glendale Galleria consistently rank among the city's top shopping centers, featuring a mix of high-end brands, popular retailers, and entertainment options.
2,445