Speed Bumps: Good or Not?
Curated by
altamira
3 min read
34
Speed bumps and humps are controversial traffic calming measures designed to reduce vehicle speeds in residential areas and parking lots. While effective at slowing traffic, they come with drawbacks like increased noise, vehicle damage, and emergency response delays. Rubber speed bumps have emerged as a popular alternative to traditional asphalt or concrete, offering benefits like recyclability, flexibility, and easier installation. However, debate continues over the overall environmental impact and effectiveness of speed bumps compared to other traffic calming techniques.
Pros and Cons of Speed Bumps
While moderately effective at reducing vehicle speeds and accident rates, speed bumps come with significant drawbacks. They can be expensive to install and maintain over time, potentially damage vehicles traversed at high speeds, and delay emergency response times for fire trucks and ambulances1. Additionally, speed bumps increase noise levels in neighborhoods due to rapid deceleration and acceleration, and may cause drivers to divert to other streets, simply moving the problem elsewhere1. Some residents oppose their installation due to these issues. As a result, many municipalities are moving away from speed bumps in favor of alternative traffic calming measures that offer similar benefits with fewer downsides.
1 source
Materials for Rubber Speed Bumps
Recycled rubber from old tires forms the primary component of most rubber speed bumps, offering durability and environmental benefits. These traffic calming devices incorporate reflective markings or bright colors to enhance visibility for drivers1. Engineered rubber compounds provide toughness to withstand heavy traffic and extreme weather conditions. Many designs feature a modular structure, allowing for easy installation, removal, and relocation as needed1. This flexibility in construction and use of recycled materials contributes to the sustainability of rubber speed bumps compared to alternatives like asphalt or concrete.
1 source
Environmental Benefits of Rubber
Utilizing recycled materials in production significantly reduces waste and the need for virgin rubber. By moderating vehicle speeds, these traffic calming devices help lower fuel consumption and greenhouse gas emissions1. The flexible nature of rubber absorbs some noise generated by vehicles traversing the bumps, reducing overall noise pollution. Installation typically requires minimal excavation, preserving natural habitats and vegetation that filter air pollutants2. However, proper maintenance and disposal are crucial to maximize environmental benefits, as deteriorating rubber bumps can release small particles into the environment over time.
2 sources
Alternatives to Rubber Speed Bumps
Several alternatives to rubber speed bumps offer varying benefits for traffic calming. Asphalt and concrete remain traditional choices, providing durability and integration with existing road surfaces. Innovative materials like thermoplastic and polyurethane offer flexibility similar to rubber, absorbing impact well and resisting weather damage. Recycled plastic speed bumps present an eco-friendly option, while metal versions suit industrial settings with heavy vehicle traffic. Quick-setting cobblestone speed bumps blend aesthetic appeal with modern materials for rapid installation. Each alternative has unique advantages in terms of cost, durability, and impact on vehicles, with the choice often depending on specific location requirements and local regulations12.
2 sources
Related
What are the advantages of using chicanes over speed bumps
How effective are median diverters in reducing traffic speed
Can corner radii be used in all types of intersections
What are the disadvantages of using traffic signals for traffic calming
How do speed cameras compare to other traffic calming measures