oxygen.com
The Michael Peterson Trial: A Closer Look at the Case
Curated by
cdteliot
6 min read
11,548
15
Michael Peterson, a novelist, was convicted in 2003 of murdering his wife Kathleen, who was found dead at the bottom of a staircase in their home, but the case took an unexpected turn years later when he was granted a new trial.
Early life and service
valor.militarytimes....
Michael Peterson enlisted in the United States Marine Corps in 1968 and served in Vietnam from August 1968 to September 1969.
1
2
He was commissioned as a second lieutenant and later promoted to captain. 2
Peterson was awarded the Silver Star for gallantry and intrepidity in action while serving with the 1st Marine Division in Vietnam. 3
However, there are conflicting accounts regarding the details of the combat incident that earned him the Silver Star. 4
4 sources
Marriages and Family
popsugar.com
Michael Peterson married his first wife Patricia Sue in 1965, and they had two sons together - Clayton and Todd Peterson.
1
2
After divorcing Patricia in the 1980s, Peterson married Kathleen Atwater in 1997. 1
3
Together with Kathleen's daughter Caitlin from a previous marriage and Peterson's adopted daughters Margaret and Martha Ratliff, they formed a blended family of five children. 1
2
3
3 sources
Legal Turmoil and Resolution: Navigating Complex Court Battles
aetv.com
On December 9, 2001, Kathleen Peterson was found dead at the bottom of a staircase in the home she shared with her husband Michael in Durham, North Carolina.
1
Michael called 911 claiming Kathleen must have fallen down the stairs after drinking alcohol and taking Valium. 2
However, the autopsy revealed Kathleen had suffered seven lacerations to her head consistent with blunt force trauma, leading investigators to suspect homicide. 1
2
In 2003, Michael Peterson was convicted of first-degree murder for Kathleen's death and sentenced to life in prison without parole. 3
The prosecution argued Peterson killed Kathleen to cover up his bisexuality and alleged financial troubles, suggesting she may have discovered his secret gay life. 1
4
Peterson maintained his innocence, claiming their marriage was happy and Kathleen accepted his bisexuality. 1
4
After serving 8 years in prison, Peterson was granted a new trial in 2011 when a key prosecution witness was found to have given misleading testimony. 1
In 2017, Peterson submitted an Alford plea to the lesser charge of voluntary manslaughter, allowing him to assert his innocence while acknowledging sufficient evidence for a conviction. 1
5
He was sentenced to time served and released from prison. 5
5 sources
Suspicious Staircase Death: Elizabeth Ratliff's Case and Its Connection to Michael Peterson
cosmopolitan.com
In 1985, Elizabeth Ratliff, a close friend of Michael and Patricia Peterson, was found dead at the bottom of her staircase in Germany with head injuries similar to Kathleen Peterson's.
1
2
Ratliff's death was initially ruled an accident caused by a cerebral hemorrhage. 3
However, during Peterson's trial, Ratliff's body was exhumed for a second autopsy by the same medical examiner who concluded Kathleen's death was a homicide. 2
4
This second autopsy overturned the original findings, listing Ratliff's cause of death as homicide by blunt force trauma. 2
4
Witnesses also testified about a large amount of blood at the scene, contradicting initial police reports. 4
5
While not accusing Peterson of Ratliff's death, prosecutors suggested the similarities gave him the idea to stage Kathleen's death as an accidental fall. 2
3
4
The admissibility of the Ratliff evidence became grounds for Peterson's appeal, as his lawyers argued the second autopsy lacked impartiality. 2
5
The striking parallels between the two deaths raised doubts about the circumstances and potential foul play involved.5 sources
The 2006 Appeal: Thomas Maher Represents Peterson in North Carolina Court
people.com
Peterson's defense counsel, with Thomas Maher as his new court-appointed attorney, filed an appeal that was argued before the North Carolina Court of Appeals in April 2006.
1
In September 2006, the Court of Appeals rejected Peterson's claims that judicial mistakes deprived him of a fair trial, stating the evidence was properly admitted despite finding defects in a search warrant. 2
3
Since the ruling was not unanimous, Peterson had the right to appeal to the North Carolina Supreme Court under state law. 2
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in September 2007 and ultimately affirmed the lower court's decision in November 2007, exhausting Peterson's appeals of the verdict. 4
In November 2008, Peterson's new attorneys filed a motion for a new trial on three grounds: the prosecution withheld exculpatory evidence about a blow poke tool, used an unqualified expert witness, and had a racially biased juror. 5
However, this motion was denied by the Durham County Superior Court in March 2009. 5
Despite multiple appeals over several years challenging his conviction, the courts consistently upheld the guilty verdict against Peterson until he was eventually granted a new trial in 2011 based on different grounds. 1
2
3
4
5
5 sources
Extensive Media Coverage: The Michael Peterson Case Captivates Public Interest
variety.com
The Michael Peterson case has been extensively covered across various media formats, generating widespread public interest and debate. Here is a concise overview:
-
The French documentary series "The Staircase" by Jean-Xavier de Lestrade provided an in-depth look at the case from Peterson's arrest to his Alford plea. 12It was later expanded with new episodes and released on Netflix.3
- Several television shows and films have dramatized or analyzed the case, including:
-
The case has been covered in numerous books like "Written in Blood" by Diane Fanning, "A Perfect Husband" by Aphrodite Jones, and Peterson's own memoirs. 45
-
Various podcasts have analyzed the evidence and theories, such as "Criminal: Animal Instincts," "The Generation Why Podcast," "BBC Radio 5 Live: Beyond Reasonable Doubt?," and "My Favorite Murder." 4
5 sources
Military Record Controversy: Michael Peterson's Background Questioned in Court
journalnow.com
Michael Peterson's military record became a point of controversy during the investigation and trial. He had initially claimed to receive two Purple Hearts for combat injuries in Vietnam, but later admitted this was false.
1
2
3
Peterson's military file verified he received the Silver Star and Bronze Star with Valor, but the Purple Hearts were actually awarded for injuries sustained in a car accident in Japan after his tour in Vietnam had ended. 2
4
According to reports, Peterson served in the Vietnam War from August 1968 to September 1969 with the 1st Marine Division. 1
2
After returning to the U.S., he was transferred to San Diego and later to Japan, where he was severely injured in a car crash while working security at a naval facility. 4
It was this non-combat incident that resulted in Peterson receiving a Purple Heart and medical retirement from the Marines. 2
4
When questioned about the discrepancy in his previous claims, Peterson admitted his story about the Purple Hearts from Vietnam was "a cover," as he did not want to discuss the details of the car accident in Japan. 4
The false claims about his military honors and combat injuries became a key issue during the legal proceedings surrounding his wife Kathleen's death. 1
2
3
4 sources
The Owl Theory: Did a Barred Owl Attack Kathleen Peterson, Leading to Her Death?
esquire.com
The "owl theory" proposes that Kathleen Peterson was attacked by a barred owl outside her home, causing the severe lacerations on her scalp that led to her death from blood loss.
1
2
This theory was first raised in 2009 by attorney T. Lawrence Pollard, who noticed microscopic feathers and wood slivers in Kathleen's hair that were listed as evidence. 1
3
Proponents argue the wounds match talon patterns from owl attacks, and Kathleen may have gone outside to put up Christmas decorations before the alleged owl encounter. 2
4
However, the medical examiner maintained the injuries were too deep to be caused by a bird. 1
Despite some experts supporting the plausibility of the owl theory, it was never officially accepted by the court as part of Peterson's defense. 2
4
4 sources
Lead Defense Attorney David Rudolf: Peterson's Guilt Not Proven Beyond Reasonable Doubt
newsobserver.com
David Rudolf, Peterson's lead defense attorney, firmly believed the prosecution's case rested entirely on circumstantial evidence and failed to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
1
2
He felt there was significant exculpatory evidence that was overlooked, such as the lack of defensive wounds suggesting a violent confrontation. 2
3
Rudolf criticized the Durham County prosecution and Durham County Superior Court for their unwillingness to consider alternative theories like the "owl theory" and their focus on portraying Peterson's bisexuality as a motive. 1
4
Rudolf also highlighted the striking similarities between Kathleen's death and that of Elizabeth Ratliff, a close family friend who died in 1985 under eerily similar circumstances in Germany. 2
5
He questioned why the blood spatter analyst's findings differed so drastically between the two cases, suggesting potential bias or misconduct. 1
3
5
Throughout the lengthy legal battle, Rudolf remained steadfast in his belief in Peterson's innocence and commended the unwavering support shown by Peterson's biological daughter Caitlin Atwater. 2
4
While respecting Peterson's decision to accept the Alford plea, Rudolf hoped the case would prompt reforms to prevent similar injustices and maintained the evidence did not prove guilt. 1
2
4
5 sources
Related
what was the significance of the blood spatter evidence in the case
how did the defense team use circumstantial evidence to build their case
what role did Elizabeth Ratliff play in the defense strategy
Keep Reading
Candy Montgomery: 1980 Axe Murderer
Candy Montgomery, a Texas housewife, became the center of a shocking murder case in 1980 when she was accused of brutally killing her friend Betty Gore with an axe. The gruesome crime and subsequent trial, in which Montgomery claimed self-defense and was ultimately acquitted, captivated the nation and left a lasting impact on the small town of Wylie, Texas.
20,299
Betty Broderick: The True Story Behind the Infamous Murders
Betty Broderick, a former suburban housewife, sparked a national debate about domestic violence after she murdered her ex-husband, Daniel T. Broderick III, and his second wife, Linda Kolkena Broderick, on November 5, 1989. The high-profile case, which resulted in Broderick's conviction for second-degree murder and a sentence of 32-years-to-life in prison, attracted extensive media attention and raised questions about the psychological effects of an acrimonious divorce.
16,532
Lisa McVey: The Incredible Story of Surviving Abduction
Lisa McVey Noland is an American police officer who, at age 17, was abducted and sexually assaulted by serial killer Bobby Joe Long before courageously escaping and helping police capture him in 1984.
6,837