food52.com
What's the British Take on American Scones?
Curated by
mranleec
6 min read
404
The distinction between American and British scones has led to some confusion in culinary terminology across the Atlantic. While British scones are typically plain or fruit-flavored and served with clotted cream and jam, American scones are often sweeter, denser, and come in a variety of flavors, leading Brits to simply refer to them as "American scones" when encountered.
What are American Scones?
americastestkitchen....
American scones are a unique interpretation of traditional British teatime treats, adapted to suit American tastes and culinary preferences. Unlike their British counterparts, American scones are typically sweeter, denser, and more indulgent, often resembling a cross between a biscuit and a cake
1
2
. These pastries are made with flour, butter, sugar, and cream, resulting in a rich, buttery texture that is more substantial than the lighter British version. American scones frequently incorporate a variety of mix-ins, such as chocolate chips, dried fruits, or nuts, directly into the dough1
3
. Popular flavors include blueberry, cranberry, and orange, but the possibilities are endless. The addition of these ingredients makes American scones more of a standalone treat, often enjoyed for breakfast or as a snack, rather than as part of an afternoon tea ritual4
.
In terms of shape, American scones are often triangular or wedge-shaped, distinguishing them from the round British scones3
. They may be topped with a sweet glaze or sprinkled with coarse sugar for added texture and sweetness. While a British person might find American scones overly sweet and cake-like, they have become a staple in American bakeries and coffee shops, reflecting the American preference for bolder flavors and more substantial portions4
3
. Incorporating elements from biscuit gravy, bread, and cookie recipes, these scones are a versatile dish in American cuisine, akin to other food items like pudding and meat dishes, and have become an integral part of American life, much like traditional British desserts in their own culture.4 sources
The British Perspective on American Scones
sallysbakingaddictio...
British people often view American scones as a distinct and somewhat perplexing culinary creation, quite different from their own traditional teatime treat. To a British person, American scones can appear more like a sweet cake or cookie than the light, plain scones they're accustomed to
1
2
. The higher sugar content and abundance of butter in American versions often surprise British palates, who are used to scones being a vehicle for clotted cream and jam rather than a standalone sweet3
. The inclusion of chocolate chips, fruits like strawberries, or other mix-ins directly in the dough is seen as unusual, as British scones are typically plain or contain only sultanas4
. Moreover, the idea of eating scones for breakfast rather than as part of an afternoon tea can seem odd to Brits, who view scones as a specific component of their traditional cream tea ritual5
. While some British people may appreciate the variety and creativity of American scones, others might find them overly indulgent and more akin to a dessert than the simpler, more versatile scone they know from their own cuisine.5 sources
What's the Difference Between British and American Scones?
thespruceeats.com
| Characteristic | British Scones | American Scones |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Flour, baking powder, salt, butter, milk, small amount of sugar 2 | Flour, baking powder, salt, more butter, heavy cream, eggs, higher sugar content 2 |
| Texture | Light, fluffy, and delicate with a crust-like exterior 3 | Dense, buttery, and crumbly 2 |
| Shape | Round and tall 3 | Often triangular or wedge-shaped 2 |
| Common Flavors | Plain or with sultanas/raisins 3 | Blueberry, raspberry, cranberry, orange, chocolate chips 4 |
| Sweetness | Less sweet 2 | Sweeter 2 |
| Preparation | Minimal handling to maintain light texture 3 | More butter incorporated, often with fruit mixed in 2 |
| Serving | Split and topped with clotted cream and jam 3 | Often eaten as-is or with a light glaze 4 |
| Occasion | Afternoon tea, cream tea 3 | Breakfast, coffee shop snack 2 |
| Cultural Significance | Traditional part of British tea time 3 | Popular coffee shop and bakery item 2 |
2
3
4
.5 sources
The Battle of Scones: Recipe and Technique Variations
bakingwithflava.co.u...
British and American scone recipes differ significantly in their ingredient proportions and baking techniques, reflecting the distinct culinary traditions of each country. British scones typically use less butter and sugar, resulting in a lighter, more bread-like texture. The recipe often calls for self-raising flour or a combination of all-purpose flour and baking powder, with just enough butter to create a tender crumb
1
. In contrast, American scones incorporate more butter and sugar, yielding a richer, sweeter pastry that's closer to a cookie or cake in texture3
.
The mixing method also varies between the two styles. British scones are made using a technique similar to biscuit-making, where cold butter is cut into the flour until it resembles coarse crumbs. This method, along with minimal handling of the dough, contributes to the light, flaky texture characteristic of British scones1
. American recipes often cream the butter and sugar together before adding the dry ingredients, resulting in a denser, more uniform texture5
. While British scones are typically round and relatively plain, allowing for the addition of jam and clotted cream, American versions are often shaped into triangles and may include mix-ins like chocolate chips or fruit directly in the dough3
. These differences in recipe and technique reflect the broader distinctions between British desserts and American baked goods, showcasing how a simple food item like the scone can evolve to suit different cultural tastes and culinary traditions.5 sources
Savoring Scones: The British or the American Way?
aimeeprovence.com.au
The traditional British way to enjoy scones is as part of a cream tea, typically served in the afternoon. British scones, resembling a cross between a biscuit and a cake, are split horizontally and topped with clotted cream and strawberry jam. The order of applying cream and jam is a subject of debate, with Devon preferring cream first, while Cornwall favors jam first. These scones are designed to be vehicles for toppings, making them a staple in British desserts. For a truly British experience, serve scones with a pot of hot tea, a time-honored tradition that enriches British cuisine and life
1
.
In contrast, American scones are often enjoyed as standalone treats, frequently eaten for breakfast or as a coffee shop snack. They may be served with butter or topped with a sweet glaze. With higher sugar content and mix-ins like chocolate chips or fruits, American versions are more akin to cookies or sweet bread. These scones, often considered a variation of pudding or other sweet food items, are best enjoyed fresh and warm, ideally on the day they are baked 2
3
. Whether paired with coffee or served as a unique dish in different recipes, both types of scones highlight the versatility of flour-based treats in various culinary traditions.3 sources
Rock Cakes: A Close American Scone Relative
thespruceeats.com
Rock cakes, a traditional British teatime treat, share some similarities with American scones in texture and preparation. These small, rustic cakes are made from a stiff dough of flour, butter, sugar, and dried fruit, resulting in a crumbly texture that falls between a cookie and a scone
1
2
. Like American scones, rock cakes are denser and more buttery than their British scone counterparts, often containing dried fruits such as currants or raisins3
. The dough is typically rolled into small, rough-textured balls before baking, giving them their characteristic "rocky" appearance1
.
While not as sweet as American scones, rock cakes offer a similar standalone treat experience, making them a popular choice for afternoon tea or as a quick snack2
. Despite their differences, both rock cakes and American scones represent variations on the theme of simple, satisfying baked goods that have found their place in their respective culinary traditions3
. Whether enjoyed with a scone biscuit gravy, or as part of a bread flour recipe, these treats are a testament to the rich variety of British desserts and food items.3 sources
Closing Thoughts on British and American Scones
Scones, whether British or American, have become beloved food items that transcend cultural boundaries. From the traditional British afternoon tea to the American coffee shop, these versatile treats have found their place in culinary life on both sides of the Atlantic. While British scones are often plain, served with clotted cream and strawberry jam, their American counterparts embrace a wider range of flavors, including chocolate chips and various fruits. The differences extend beyond just ingredients; British scones are more akin to a light biscuit, while American versions lean towards a sweeter, cake-like texture. Despite these variations, both types share a common ancestry in simple bread recipes, elevated by butter and sugar. Whether you prefer the classic British cream tea experience or the indulgent American interpretation, scones remain a delightful dish that continues to evolve. From traditional afternoon tea to modern dessert menus, scones have proven their adaptability across cuisines and cultures, satisfying sweet tooths and comforting food lovers worldwide.
1
2
4
5 sources
Related
What are some creative ways to use leftover scone dough
How can I incorporate British desserts into a modern brunch menu
What are the best British desserts to serve at a dinner party
How do I make a traditional British afternoon tea spread
What are some unique British dessert recipes to try
